AllSainter
Member

****
...

fabio
Member

***
weniger

Getharda
Member

****
Akzeptabel, aber nicht wirklich berührend und dadurch dann langweilig. Knappe 4*.
Last edited: 29.07.2011 18:53

Der_Nagel
Member

****
zweite Single aus dem selbstbetitelten 2011er Album...ein beruhigendes, gemütliches Stück der amerikanischen Indie Folk-Band – aufgerundete 3.5... ihre Musik passt unglaublich gut in den Winter...
Last edited: 10.01.2012 21:47

bjorn614
Member

*****
Lekker rustig :p

gherkin
Member

******
Misschien wordt dit wel die grote hit die Bon Iver al een hele tijd verdient. Ik duim.

jeankeL
Member

*****
zeer mooi nummer

Marc the Mike
Member

*****
Met Bon Iver is het een beetje als met Dylan: wondermooie liedjes, maar een irritante stem. Dit is wel zijn mooiste tot nog toe.

Hijinx
Member

****
I really just did not like this when I heard it and thought it sounded like all their other songs. Despite this I was still completely rooting for it to win a Grammy because Arcade Fire had proven the year prior that much hilarity can surface from it. This particular song didn't win but Bon Iver still won another Grammy and fun was had. But I really think that it's a shame that this didn't win a Grammy because it really is a beautiful song, with plenty of phrases that get stuck in my head. I could hear The National performing this song (with more drumming of course!). By some strange twist of fate, this 5 and a half minute long song with the same riff repeated from start to finish happens to be the only Bon Iver song I would go so far as to say I like, magic stuff!
Last edited: 29.08.2012 18:02

Kamala
Member

*****
Das ist besinnliche Musik, das ist eine Geschichte - schön erzählt - aber zuhören muss man ihr!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TWcyIpul8OE

Snormobiel Beusichem
Member

**
▒ Helaas staat me de zangstem van "Justin Vernon" op deze, overigens ook zéér zwakke, indieplaat uit ½ juni 2011 me totaal niet aan !!! Néé geef me dan toch maar liever een echte 'goede winter' ☺!!!

irelander
Member

***
I don't mind it.

zxcvcxz
Member

*****
Sublime.

bluezombie
Member

***
It's okay.

liam99
Member

**
It's alright.

Chris A
Member

**
Such a boring song.

Widmann1
Member

**
Bon und ich werden keine Kumpels.

remember
Member

***
Wie seine Songs ähnlich klingen, lesen sich auch die reviews dazu immer gleich (Winter, Atmosphäre, nachdenken, blabla).
Von den ME Lesern zur #17 der besten Songs des Jahres 2011 gewählt.

HeadInAMuse
Member

****
Pretty good, like most here I'm sorta unsure whether he's worth the hype (his stuff with Kanye in 2010 was very good) but this seems promising

BeansterBarnes
Member

*
TRASH!